Why Google Rankings Change So Much So Soon

If you're publishing content regularly on your blog/website (and I hope you are - it's still a great way to attract traffic and leads!), you may have experienced the joy of publishing something one day and seeing it rank high on Google the next day.

Such a great feeling!

You may also have experienced the feeling of seeing that high ranking disappear -- sometimes a few spots at a time over a couple days or weeks, or sometimes it's a drop of a few pages instantly.

What in the actual $#!@%$# is going on??

Here's the deal: It usually takes a couple weeks/months for new content to settle in where Google thinks it should rank.

I'm using the phrase "settle in" very cautiously there because rankings are always subject to change. But rankings are much more volatile when content is first published. Here's why....

Why content sometimes ranks high right after publishing

First, understand that Google generally values new/fresh content over old content to answer informational searches. There are exceptions to every rule, but a 2026 article with advice for people relocating to your city is likely to be more favored (both by Google and AI sites...and searchers!) than an article written in 2018.

(Tip: This is why you should regularly update old content in addition to publishing new content.)

Now, when you publish a new page or blog post and it ranks really high right away, this most commonly happens because one or both of these are true:

1. You have a strong website that Google trusts, and/or

2. Your new content has very little competition, so of course it ranks high

New content can rank really high, really fast, because Google doesn’t have enough signals to know where your content really belongs -- it has no user signals, no inbound links, etc. So if there’s not much competition (i.e., not many articles like yours), or if you have a strong website that Google generally trusts, it might place your new content high on page 1.

This is essentially Google half-predicting and half-testing your content to figure out where it really belongs.

Why early rankings often change

So you've just published this great article and it quickly ranked high on page 1. At this point, Google’s systems and algorithms will do their thing and start looking for and processing signals about your content:

• Does your new content have many quality inbound links? (good signal)

• Does it have quality internal links from your own site? (good signal)

• When people see this new content in the search results, are they clicking on it or scrolling past? (good signal if they click)

• If they click on it, do they quickly return to the search results and then click on a different article? (bad signal -- we call this "pogo-sticking")

Based on all of this (and more), the flux period begins. Your new page/article might move up and down on page 1, and maybe even off page 1. Maybe someday it’ll get back to where it started. Maybe it won’t.

I’ve seen this flux period last as little as 1-2 weeks and as much as 2-3 months. Eventually, Google figures out where your content should "settle in."

At that point, it’s on you (internal links, inbound links, etc.) and Google’s users (lots of clicks, little pogo-sticking, etc.) to show that it either belongs where it settled, or belongs higher based on all the other content it's up against.

That’s what SEO is and does.

Your takeaways: Don’t be surprised if your content ranks great in week 1, then not so great for the next couple weeks or months. Google initially tries to predict where new content belongs based on the strength of your site, how much competing content exists, and other signals. As it processes those signals, your rankings will probably change. While all that is happening, you can influence Google by continuing to do high-quality SEO that sends good signals.

If you liked this article, you'll love my newsletter. Marketing Unlocked arrives in your inbox every other Sunday at 6:00 a.m. ET. You can unsubscribe anytime, but 500+ of your industry peers are reading it and raving about it. Click here to learn why and subscribe.